Scary Cincy Sites

The city of Cincinnati has a rich history. And, this time of year, a rich history can only mean one thing – ghost stories. We’ve compiled a list of the top 5 most haunted sites in the city. So, get ready to get scared.

1. Spring Grove Cemetery

The cholera outbreak of the 1830’s and 40’s made a big cemetery in Cincinnati a necessity. Since then, Spring Grove has been the final resting place for many famous Cincinnatians. Among them, are William Cooper Procter and James Norris Gamble (the founders of P&G), and Bernard Kroger (who started the largest chain of supermarkets in the country). You’ll also find 34 Civil War generals, ten governors from three states and countless unique and beautiful mausoleums and memorials.

Want to see something creepy? Check out the large bust in section 100 to see the eyes that follow you wherever you go. Legend has it that the bust was made with real eyes.

2. Cincinnati Music Hall

This beautiful building in Over-the-Rhine was built in 1870 on top of a potter’s field (an unmarked cemetery for poor people). Since then, the building has been used for the 1880 Democratic National Convention and is currently a National Historic Landmark that is home to the Cincinnati Opera and Cincinnati Symphony Orchestra.

Many music hall workers and janitors have reported haunting tales of voices, whispering and singing when the building was otherwise empty.

3. Cornell Place Apartments

This Victorian mansion at 3517 Cornell Place was built in 1850. In the 156 years of its existence, Cornell Place has been a private residence, a school for girls and is now a private apartment dwelling.

Aside from its current residents, rumor has it that several ghosts also occupy the mansion. At least two suicides and one murder have occurred here, and the ghosts are responsible for footsteps, strange voices and other unexplained incidents.

4. Mother of Mercy High School

This college-prep Catholic high school settled in Western Hills boasts a history of 87 years and over 10,000 graduates.

A ghost named Sister Mary Carlos allegedly haunts the school’s auditorium. From flickering lights to mysteriously disappearing props, this ghost has a reputation for creating chaos during shows. As a result, the school’s drama department has made it a tradition to invite her to every show.

5. Eden Park

Named after the Garden of Eden, this gorgeous park is home to the Cincinnati Art Museum, Cincinnati Art Academy, Playhouse in the Park and much, much more. A blissful getaway for Cincinnatians since 1859, Eden Park is one of the most attractive sites in the entire city.

It’s also one of the most haunted. As the story goes, a husband murdered his wife at the gazebo at Mirror Lake. Known as the “Lady in Black,” her ghost haunts the area with frequent visits. However, she hasn’t discouraged countless couples from getting married at this exact spot.